Nailed it

Halloween cookies.  They're supposed to look like this:



And instead they look like this:

Aw yeah.

Recipe here: http://www.marthastewart.com/356428/ladies-fingers#Halloween%20Cookie%20Recipes|/275516/halloween-cookie-recipes/@center/1006805/halloween-recipes|356428

If you want to cheap out and use frosting for the fingernails it may be worth applying the frosting after baking.  Just a thought.